Joint review of sport, leisure and cultural services

Eildon - facility change proposals

Detailed below are the property change proposals in Berwickshire put forward by the independent consultants in April 2025 following their review and the joint recommendations we have developed with Live Borders following community and stakeholder consultation and engagement.

A special meeting of Council will consider the recommendations on Thursday 20 November.

Further details on the options appraisal scoring and rationale can be found in Appendix 3 for the Council meeting.

Galashiels

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Queens Leisure Centre Consultants' Proposal: Proceed with closure and migrate bookings to new High School; sell land

N/A - this facility did not form part of the scoring exercise as in line with the previous decision of Council relating to the new Galashiels Academy Campus, it will close during 2026 when all current activities have been relocated.

Galashiels Swimming Pool Consultants' Proposal: Retain, ensuring daytime access to new High School pool.

N/A - a new pool will open within the new Academy as planned.

Old Gala House Consultants' Proposal: Proceed with closure due to low footfall.

Retain Old Gala House whilst disposal of the property is sought via community asset transfer or other means, to the benefit of the Galashiels Common Good Fund and the residents of Galashiels with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029. As this is a common good asset a further consultation would be required to comply with the principles of the law regarding common good assets at the point that any asset transfer is being considered.

Focus Centre Consultants' Proposal: Close and transfer activities to Volunteer Hall and new High School or pursue Community Asset Transfer where viable.

Close the Focus Centre and relocate activities to a remodelled Langlee Community Centre and other sites to maximise the benefits for the community, support property rationalisation and deliver reduced associated property costs.  

Trifitness Consultants' Proposal: Dispose of and migrate to the repurposed Tweedbank Bowling Hall to a state-of-the-art fitness centre, replacing the Trifitness Centre.

Retain TriFitness and maximise usage and income generation.

Melrose

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Melrose Corn Exchange/Ormiston Institute Consultants' Proposal: Retain with increased commercialisation strategies or partnership could be explored including Community Asset Transfer of the Ormiston/Corn Exchange building to Trimontium.

Retain Corn Exchange/Ormiston Institute whilst opportunities are explored to maximise usage and income generation with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029, subject to a robust and sustainable business case being presented to the benefit of the Ormiston Trust for Institute. As this is a trust asset additional legal steps would be required before this recommendation can be progressed.

Earlston

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Earlston Library Consultants' Proposal: Close and expand mobile library services.

N/A - the library has been relocated to the new primary school, as intended.

Lauder

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Lauder Public Hall Consultants' Proposal: Proceed with closure or Community Asset Transfer, ensuring alternative access for users

Retain Lauder Public Hall whilst opportunities are explored to maximise usage and income generation with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029, subject to a robust and sustainable business case being presented. As this is a common good asset a further consultation would be required to comply with the principles of the law regarding common good assets at the point that any asset transfer is being considered.

Stow

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Stow Town Hall Consultants' Proposal: Proceed with closure or transfer to community ownership (Community Asset Transfer) ensuring alternative access for users.

Retain Stow Town Hall and seek to maximise usage and income generation with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029, subject to a robust and sustainable business case being presented. At the point that this progresses to an asset transfer request there will need to be a further legal process since this property is held by SBC as a trust.

Langlee

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Langlee Community Centre Consultants' Proposal: Proceed with closure and activity transfer to Volunteer Hall and new High School.

Retain Langlee Community Centre and remodel to stimulate and maximise community activities in an improved, vibrant facility, increasing usage and income generation, including through the relocation of activities currently taking place at the Focus Centre.

Newtown St Boswells

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Newtown Community Wing Consultants' Proposal: Close or pursue Community Asset Transfer where viable

Retain Newtown St Boswells Community Wing and introduce a new management/operating model to maximise usage and income generation with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029 subject to a robust and sustainable business case being presented.

Selkirk

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Selkirk Leisure Centre Consultants' Proposal: Consider closure and redistribute access to Galashiels Swimming Pool.

Regarding Selkirk Leisure Centre and Caravan Park, request that officers work with the community with the aim of establishing a robust and sustainable business case for a full Community Asset Transfer and community-led operation or any other 3rd party operational arrangements. Recognises ongoing Council revenue funding would be required to support a community operation. A further report to Council will be required on this proposal at such time as a request for Council funding is received, or if urgent capital investment is required to support ongoing operation of the facility. If there is no viable community or 3rd party solution by 31 March 2029 the facility will close and consultation on disposal will be progressed, in accordance with law regarding common good assets.

Halliwell’s House Museum Consultants' Proposal: Close

Retain Halliwell's House Museum and co-locate Selkirk library service into the building and progress with development of a shared access arrangement with Sir Walter Scott’s Courtroom which allows staffing rationalisation and increased footfall across both sites. Pursue disposal of the Library building.

Sir Walter Scott’s Courtroom Consultants' Proposal: Close or integrate with Selkirk Library

Retain Halliwell's House Museum and co-locate Selkirk library service into the building and progress with development of a shared access arrangement with Sir Walter Scott’s Courtroom which allows staffing rationalisation and increased footfall across both sites. Pursue disposal of the Library building.

Selkirk Library Consultants' Proposal: Retain; explore consolidation with Sir Walter Scott’s Courtroom or alternative service models Retain Halliwell's House Museum and co-locate Selkirk library service into the building and progress with development of a shared access arrangement with Sir Walter Scott’s Courtroom which allows staffing rationalisation and increased footfall across both sites. Pursue disposal of the Library building.
Argus Community Centre Consultants' Proposal: Close or transfer to Community Asset Transfer

Retain Argus Community Centre and maximise usage and income generation, whilst a long-term proposition is developed, to be shaped by discussions with existing tenant and user groups exploring options which enable property rationalisation and support early learning, educational and community benefits within Selkirk.

Selkirk Caravan Park Consultants' Proposal: Dispose of or Community Asset Transfer

Regarding Selkirk Leisure Centre and Caravan Park, request that officers work with the community with the aim of establishing a robust and sustainable business case for a full Community Asset Transfer and community-led operation or any other 3rd party operational arrangements. Recognises ongoing Council revenue funding would be required to support a community operation. A further report to Council will be required on this proposal at such time as a request for Council funding is received, or if urgent capital investment is required to support ongoing operation of the facility. If there is no viable community or 3rd party solution by 31 March 2029 the facility will close and consultation on disposal will be progressed, in accordance with law regarding common good assets.

Tweedbank

Service/Property Proposals within Integratis report Recommendation to be considered by Council
Tweedbank Sports Centre and Bowling Hall Consultants' Proposal: Retain and repurpose the bowling hall to a state of the are fitness centre, replacing the TriFitness centre.

Retain Tweedbank Sports Centre and Bowling Hall and undertake property feasibility works to identify opportunities to maximise usage and income and associated investment requirements.

Tweedbank Community Centre Consultants' Proposal: Close or pursue Community Asset Transfer where viable.

Retain Tweedbank Community Centre and introduce a new management/operating model to maximise usage and income generation with a view to a full community asset transfer being completed by 31 March 2029 subject to a robust and sustainable business case being presented.